Why do companies and major economies use consultants? What independent research says
The Gulf spends over $8 billion a year on consulting, and a randomised trial in India raised productivity 17%. The real benefits, the documented failures, when you do not need a consultant, and eight questions before you sign.
Let us start honestly: we are a consulting firm, and we have an obvious interest in convincing you that consulting is useful. So we wrote this article differently. We will not only list the benefits. We will show what independent research says, how the largest economies spend on this sector, and where the big consulting firms have also gone wrong. Then we leave the verdict to you.
Many business owners in Iraq ask a simple question: why should I pay someone from outside my company to tell me what to do inside it? The shortest answer: what holds companies back most is not a lack of intelligence, but a lack of information, time and enough distance to see the whole picture.
How much does the world spend on consulting?
- The Gulf: the consulting market in the GCC grew to more than $8.3 billion in 2025, with growth expected at 12%. Saudi Arabia alone is about half of it, at $4.3 billion in 2024, according to Source Global Research (Consultancy-me).
- Germany: management consulting revenue reached €46.7 billion in 2023, with more than 230,000 people employed in the sector, according to the German consultancies association (BDU).
- The United States: about 1.08 million people work as management analysts and consultants, and these jobs are projected to grow 10% over ten years, much faster than average. The reason, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics: organisations are looking for ways to improve efficiency and control costs (BLS).
- The UK government: central government spent about £1.36 billion on consultants in 2022–23, by HM Treasury's estimate. 86% of respondents to a National Audit Office survey said consultants made a valuable contribution (NAO).
What stands out in the Gulf numbers is that the fastest-growing areas are energy and the shift away from oil, followed by financial services and the public sector. Two-thirds of surveyed clients expect more than 30% of their consulting budgets to go to AI adoption. The countries rebuilding their economies spend the most on consulting, not the stable ones.
What does independent research say?
The more important question is not how much countries spend, but whether that spending actually works. Here are two of the most important scientific studies on the subject. Both were randomised controlled trials, the same standard used to test medicines.
The Indian textile mills experiment
A team of researchers led by Nicholas Bloom of Stanford University gave free management consulting to randomly chosen large textile plants in India and compared them with plants that did not receive it. The result: productivity rose 17% in the first year, through better quality, higher efficiency and lower inventory. Within three years the firms opened new plants (Bloom et al., QJE 2013).
More important is why these firms had not adopted good practices before. The researchers concluded that "informational barriers" were the main factor: the firms did not know what they did not know.
The Mexican small-business experiment
In Puebla, Mexico, 150 small and medium firms, chosen at random from 432, were offered a full year of consulting, with a subsidy covering 70–90% of the cost. Researchers Miriam Bruhn, Dean Karlan and Antoinette Schoar compared them with the other firms. The results (J-PAL):
- Productivity: rose one year after the programme.
- Return on assets: also rose.
- Employment: the number of employees rose 57% relative to the comparison group over five years.
- Wages: total wages paid rose 72%.
Strikingly, the employment effect kept growing every year after the consulting ended. That means the firms did not only improve while the consultant was there; they learned a way of working that stayed with them.
What does a good consultant actually provide?
From the research above, and from the reasons governments themselves give, the real value comes down to five things:
- Breaking the information barrier. A consultant has seen your problem in other companies and knows what worked and what failed. You see your company only from the inside.
- Specialist expertise only when you need it. You do not need a full-time expert in market entry or AI all year. You need one for three months, then you move on.
- Extra capacity for a defined project. Your team is busy running the business today. A big project, such as a new system, a new branch or a restructuring, needs someone dedicated to it.
- An independent view on big decisions. When a decision is expensive and irreversible, it helps to hear from someone with no internal stake in the outcome, who is not afraid to tell you "no."
- Knowledge transfer. A good consultant leaves behind tools, a way of thinking and a team that has learned, not a report on a shelf.
The other side: when does consulting fail?
This article would not be honest without this section. The big consulting firms have documented failures:
- McKinsey: in December 2024 it agreed to pay $650 million to settle a U.S. federal investigation, after prosecutors said it advised Purdue Pharma on steps to "turbocharge" sales of the addictive drug OxyContin (Claims Journal).
- PwC Australia: a senior partner leaked confidential information about government tax plans, which he had seen while advising the government, to help other clients. An Australian Senate inquiry recommended reforming how government uses consultants (The Daily Aus).
- Over-reliance: the UK National Audit Office warned that consultants are costly and can be wasteful if used unnecessarily or if they stop an organisation from building its own capability.
Three rules follow from these examples: a consultant does not relieve you of responsibility for the decision. A consultant must never serve two conflicting sides. And you should come out of the engagement stronger, not more dependent.
When do you not need a consultant?
- When you want someone to make the decision for you, rather than help you make it.
- When the problem is day-to-day operations that your team should own.
- When nobody inside your company will own the project after the consultant leaves.
- When you are looking for a report to justify a decision you have already made.
And why does this matter in Iraq?
The Indian finding sounds very close to Iraq's reality. For many Iraqi companies, according to the World Bank's 2022 survey, the biggest barrier is not a lack of will but a lack of tools. Only 16.8% of firms offer formal staff training, and only 2.3% have bank credit (Enterprise Surveys). Most companies are run on their owner's experience alone, and learn only from their own mistakes, not from others'.
At the same time, the environment around them is changing fast: payments are becoming data, taxes are becoming systems, and AI is entering the market. At a moment like this, whoever sees the road early saves themselves years of trial and error.
How to choose a consultant: eight questions
If you decide to hire a consultant, any consultant, ask these questions before you sign:
- What exactly will I get? A clear, measurable result, not an open-ended "study."
- How will we know the work succeeded? Which indicator will change, and by when?
- Who will actually work on my project? The people you meet in the first meeting, or others?
- What will my team learn? Does the contract include knowledge transfer?
- Do you work for a competitor of mine? How do you separate conflicting clients?
- How do you protect my information? A written confidentiality agreement, and clear limits on who sees what.
- What if we disagree on the outcome? A clear process for review and resolution.
- Can you tell me "no"? A consultant who agrees with everything adds nothing.
In short
The major economies do not turn to consultants because they are weak. They do so because they know that no organisation, however large, has every kind of expertise at every moment. Independent research says good consulting raises productivity and creates jobs, and its effect lasts after it ends. But the documented cases also say bad consulting is expensive, and sometimes harmful.
What separates the two is not the size or the name of the consulting firm, but a clear goal, an honest consultant, and a company that comes out of the engagement better able to work on its own.
Sources
- Consultancy-me: GCC consulting market 2025 (Source Global Research)
- BDU: German management consulting market (Mar 2024)
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics: Management analysts
- UK National Audit Office: Government's use of consultants (Nov 2025)
- Bloom et al.: Does Management Matter? Evidence from India (QJE 2013)
- J-PAL: Consulting for small and medium firms in Mexico
- Claims Journal: McKinsey settlement (Dec 2024)
- The Daily Aus: Senate recommendations after the PwC case (Jun 2024)
- World Bank: Enterprise Surveys, Iraq 2022
Figures are reported as their sources published them. This article is general information, and we remind you that its author is a consulting firm.
This article is general information, not legal, financial or tax advice for your situation.